Feb 1, 2011 – Federal District Court Judge Roger Vinson's 78-page opinion in State of Florida v . United States Department of Health and Human Services is a .

Feb 1, 2011 – Have you actually taken the time to read Judge Vinson's opinion in the case discussed above. Have you read the Circuit Court's majority and .

Feb 1, 2011 – It's also worth noting that this assertion causes Vinson's opinion to collapse on itself. If the mandate has literally no impact on .

Feb 1, 2011 – I don't think [Chief] Justice Vinson is still issuing opinions these days. If he is, then that gives a whole new meaning to (after)life tenure! .

Feb 3, 2011 – I think that one thing about Judge Vinson's opinion, where he said that if we strike down the mandate everything else goes, shows as well as .

Feb 9, 2011 – Your best argument is through the Orin Kerr post that you linked above, The Weak Link In Judge Vinson's Opinion. His point is not exactly a .

Mar 4, 2011 – This, as Judge Vinson explained at the time, is the "functional . . (never play poker with people who view it as "living" ) , departments at the .

Jan 31, 2011 – There are four key components to Judge Vinson's opinion: (1 .

Feb 3, 2011 – Judge Roger Vinson's opinion striking down the Affordable Care Act has been widely criticized by progressives and conservatives alike, and for .

Jan 31, 2011 – There are four key components to Judge Vinson's opinion: (1) a ruling that the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act's dramatic expansion .

Feb 2, 2011 – Federal District Court Judge Roger Vinson's 78-page opinion in State of Florida v. United States Department of Health and Human Services is .

Jan 31, 2011 – Judge Roger Vinson of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of . “This is an opinion by a judge who is steeped in the history and .

Feb 2, 2011 – It's worth taking a step back and viewing Vinson's opinion, and the three others which have been issued on the mandate, in a broader context. .

Jan 31, 2011 – View Judge Vinson's 78-page ruling. Reactions from legal scholars are coming in . Here's what they have to say: Ilya Shapiro, Senior Fellow in .

Jan 31, 2011 – In Vinson's view, forcing health insurance coverage upon citizens turns the tables on origin of American democracy. Wrote Vinson: "It is difficult .

Jan 31, 2011 – In his 78-page opinion, Judge Vinson held that the insurance requirement exceeded the regulatory powers granted to Congress under the .

Jan 31, 2011 – Anyways, the judge also draws a comparison to the housing market and the "food market" as m . view full comment. To be fair, Vinson does .

Mar 3, 2011 – ABC News' Ariane de Vogue reports: In a harshly worded opinion, Judge Roger Vinson, the Florida federal judge who struck down the entire .

Feb 2, 2011 – In the accompanying interactive examination of Vinson's opinion, we show how he effectively writes an entire provision of the Constitution out of .

Feb 1, 2011 – In his 78-page opinion, Vinson, who was appointed by President Ronald Reagan , offered the most lengthy consideration to date of the legal .

Feb 1, 2011 – Read on for highlights from Judge Vinson's magisterial opinion (to which I initially responded here and whose immediate consequences I .

Feb 1, 2011 – Make no mistake, Vinson's opinion is riddled with errors .

Jan 31, 2011 – Read Judge Roger Vinson's ruling overturning President Obama's health . Health Care Ruling by Judge Vinson . View All Business News » .

Jan 31, 2011 – Following on his review of Commerce Clause jurisprudence, Judge Vinson identifies the key feature of the individual mandate that is decisive .

Vinson wrote the opinion for the plurality in Dennis v. US (1951), in which the Court upheld convictions of Communists for violating the Smith Act (which forbade .

Jan 31, 2011 – Vinson's opinion is a simple and clear reminder that ours is still a federal government of limited and enumerated powers. Not only has Vinson .

Jan 31, 2011 – Update: I'm getting some contrasting opinions of whether the ruling could impede implementation. Vinson does not grant the plaintiff's request .

Feb 2, 2011 – Federal District Judge Roger Vinson's opinion issued the other day ruling the Healthcare Act an unconstitutional overreach by Congress is so .

Feb 2, 2011 – In Vinson's view, the law is so dependent upon the mandate that it cannot function without it. Calling the mandate on health insurance the .

Jan 31, 2011 – Here is how Vinson lifts FRC's argument: Vinson's opinion: Severability is a doctrine of judicial restraint, and the Supreme Court has applied .

Feb 1, 2011 – I can buy that such an analysis is possible, but Judge Vinson's opinion doesn't actually seem to spend much of its time making the legal case. .

File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat - Quick View

Feb 2, 2011 – Why does our system allow an obscure Florida district judge to throw a monkey- wrench into the national works?

Mar 15, 2011 – In his opinion declaring the PPACA unconstitutional, Judge Vinson found the minimum coverage provision invalid under the Commerce .

Jan 31, 2011 – www.scribd.com/doc/47906407/Vinson-OpinionPrawfsBlawg: Judge Vinson's incoherent extension of Printz's anti . You +1'd this publicly. UndoJan 31, 2011 – Consider the following train wreck of Necessary & Proper reasoning contained in Judge Vinson's opinion striking down the individual mandate: .

Jan 31, 2011 – Here, the mere facts that Tea Party folk and Lochner-resurrectionists (again, I'm neither) may like the result of the Vinson opinion, and that “tea .

Feb 1, 2011 – Judge Vinson rejected that view. Under the Obama administration's logic, he wrote, "Congress could require that everyone above a certain .

Feb 1, 2011 – The federal court in the massive 26-state challenge to ObamaCare on Monday held that the health care law's individual mandate is .

Feb 6, 2011 – . my Yale Law School class on constitutional law, I began reading federal District Judge Roger Vinson's recent opinion declaring "Obamacare"

Jan 31, 2011 – Home > Opinion > Peter Roff > Federal Judge Declares Obamacare . Federal Judge Roger Vinson, a Reagan appointee, found that the .

Jan 31, 2011 – To wit, Judge Vinson offered a serious response, striking down not only the mandate, but the whole of the health care bill. In a 78-page opinion, .

Feb 5, 2011 – Judge Vinson's opinion is extensive – 78 pages – but it is also extraordinarily well-written and well-researched. It represents the judiciary's most .

Jan 31, 2011 – For most people, an "activist judge" is one whose opinions they don't agree with. But Judge Vinson's ruling today -- that the entire health care .

Feb 2, 2011 – by Beverly MannRoger Vinson, Sophism King Federal District Judge Roger Vinson's opinion issued .

Jan 31, 2011 – But Judge Vinson is just a District Court judge. And if you pair Justice Thomas's dissent in Raich with Judge Vinson's opinion today, you realize .

Feb 2, 2011 – Yesterday I finally got around to reading Judge Vinson's 78-page (!) opinion in which he held that Obamacare was unconstitutional. I am not a .

Jan 31, 2011 – Tweets that mention Judge Vinson Shuts Down Obamacare Attempts In Florida : News , Opinion, Truth & YOU! -- Topsy.com .

A prime example is Chief Justice Vinson's opinion in DENNIS v. US (1951), in which established First Amendment interpretation was turned upside down to .

Jan 31, 2011 – Judge Roger Vinson, in Pensacola, Fla., ruled that as a result of the . "We are analyzing this opinion to determine what steps, if any -- including .

Sitemap